... Follow Aliana on Pinterest →

Hannah Cooking

Christmas Sugar Cookie Shots

Published: by . Leave a Comment

My sister's annual holiday party featuring homemade everything from scratch and Pinterest perfect decorations made my usual grocery store cheese platter contributions look pathetic by comparison. The Christmas sugar cookie shots with their festive sprinkle rimmed glasses and creamy sugar cookie flavor finally gave me something impressive enough to stop feeling like the less put together sibling at family gatherings.

Creamy Christmas sugar cookie shots made with vanilla vodka, amaretto, and Irish cream for a festive, dessert-like holiday cocktail. Perfect for parties, celebrations, and impressive holiday entertaining.
Jump to Recipe Print Recipe
Festive Christmas sugar cookie shots with sprinkle-rimmed glasses filled with creamy vanilla cookie liqueur.
Festive Christmas sugar cookie shots with sprinkle-rimmed glasses filled with creamy vanilla cookie liqueur.

What is Christmas Sugar Cookie Shots

Christmas sugar cookie shots are festive holiday shooters featuring vanilla vodka, amaretto liqueur, and Irish cream or half and half that creates creamy sweet flavor mimicking sugar cookies, served in glasses rimmed with colorful Christmas sprinkles for impressive presentation. Unlike complicated layered shots requiring precise pouring techniques or shots that taste like straight alcohol burning your throat, these taste like liquid dessert that everyone actually wants to drink. The sprinkle rim transforms simple shot into Instagram worthy holiday treat that looks way more complicated than the 30 seconds it takes to shake ingredients together.

How to Make Christmas Sugar Cookie Shots

Using amaretto liqueur adds that distinct almond sugar cookie flavor that plain vanilla vodka alone can't achieve making these taste authentically like cookies not just sweet alcohol. We rim glasses with festive red green and white sprinkles which creates that holiday sugar cookie appearance while adding sweet crunch with every sip. Shaking with ice dilutes the alcohol slightly creating smoother shot that doesn't burn going down making them actually enjoyable instead of something people grimace through. The cream component can be Irish cream liqueur or plain half and half depending on whether you want stronger alcohol content or lighter version.

Christmas Sugar Cookie Shots Ingredients

For Each Shot:

  • 1 oz vanilla vodka
  • ½ oz amaretto liqueur
  • ½ oz Irish cream (Baileys) or half and half
  • Ice for shaking

For the Festive Rim:

  • Light corn syrup or honey for adhering
  • Christmas colored sprinkles (red, green, white nonpareils)
  • Optional: white chocolate for dipping rim

For Batch Making (Serves 8):

  • 1 cup vanilla vodka
  • ½ cup amaretto liqueur
  • ½ cup Irish cream or half and half
  • Shake in batches with ice
Ingredients for Christmas sugar cookie shots arranged on a white kitchen counter, including vodka, amaretto, Irish cream, and festive sprinkles.

Step by Step Method

Prepare Sprinkle Rimmed Glasses

  • Pour Christmas sprinkles onto shallow plate
  • Dip shot glass rim in corn syrup or honey
  • Roll rim in sprinkles coating evenly all around
  • Let glasses sit while preparing shots so sprinkles adhere
  • Can prepare rimmed glasses hours ahead of party

Combine Shot Ingredients

  • Add vanilla vodka, amaretto, Irish cream to cocktail shaker
  • Fill shaker with ice cubes
  • Shake vigorously for 15 seconds until well chilled
  • Shaking dilutes slightly and creates smooth texture
  • Don't skip shaking or shot tastes too strong

Strain Into Prepared Glasses

  • Strain shot mixture into prepared sprinkle rimmed glass
  • Pour carefully to avoid disturbing sprinkle rim
  • Fill shot glass leaving small space at top
  • Wipe any drips from outside of glass for clean presentation
  • Serve immediately while cold

Batch Make for Parties

  • Multiply recipe by number of guests
  • Mix all alcohol in large pitcher or shaker
  • Shake in batches with ice as needed
  • Keep mixture chilled until serving
  • Prepare sprinkle rims ahead for efficiency

Alternative Serving Options

  • Serve in regular cocktail glasses over ice as full drink
  • Use mini martini glasses for more elegant presentation
  • Create shot flight with different flavored variations
  • Serve in edible chocolate shot glasses for extra impression
  • Can make non alcoholic version with vanilla syrup and cream

What Pairs Well With Christmas Sugar Cookie Shots?

These sweet Christmas sugar cookie shots pair naturally with holiday cookies, brownies, or chocolate truffles that complement the dessert like flavor. Serve them at adult Christmas parties alongside other festive drinks like eggnog, mulled wine, or peppermint cocktails. For party appetizers, pair with cheese boards, stuffed mushrooms, or bacon wrapped dates that provide savory contrast.

Christmas Sugar Cookie Shots Variations

Sugar Cookie Shot with Vodka Only

  • Use 1.5 oz vanilla vodka and 1 oz half and half
  • Skip amaretto for simpler version with less ingredients
  • Add drop of almond extract for cookie flavor
  • Lighter alcohol content for people who want mild shots

Christmas Cookie Jello Shots Version

  • Make jello shots using vanilla vodka and amaretto
  • Add to red or green jello for festive colors
  • Top with whipped cream and sprinkles
  • Creates fun party shot alternative to liquid version

White Chocolate Sugar Cookie Shots

  • Rim glass with melted white chocolate then sprinkles
  • Add white chocolate liqueur to shot mixture
  • Creates richer more decadent flavor
  • Perfect for chocolate lovers wanting extra sweetness

Gingerbread Cookie Shots

  • Add ¼ oz ginger liqueur or splash of molasses
  • Use brown sugar for rimming instead of sprinkles
  • Add pinch of cinnamon and nutmeg to mixture
  • Creates spiced cookie flavor instead of sugar cookie

Equipment You'll Need

Essential Tools:

  • Cocktail shaker with strainer
  • Shot glasses or small cocktail glasses
  • Shallow plates for sprinkle rimming
  • Jigger for measuring accurately
  • Small brush for applying corn syrup
  • Pitcher for batch mixing

Storage Tips That Keep Them Fresh

Best Fresh

  • Christmas sugar cookie shots taste best immediately when ice cold
  • Sprinkle rims look freshest within few hours before humidity affects them
  • Pre made mixture loses some smoothness if stored too long

Make Ahead Strategy

  • Rim glasses with sprinkles up to 4 hours before party
  • Mix alcohol components and refrigerate up to 24 hours
  • Shake with ice right before serving for best texture
  • Have ingredients pre measured for quick assembly during party

Storing Components

  • Store opened amaretto and Irish cream refrigerated
  • Vanilla vodka keeps at room temperature
  • Extra sprinkle rimmed glasses stay fresh covered with plastic wrap
  • Leftover shot mixture refrigerates 2 days but quality decreases

Top Tips for Christmas Sugar Cookie Shots

My sister's elaborate holiday parties made me feel inadequate until Christmas sugar cookie shots proved that impressive presentation matters more than spending all day cooking from scratch. Using corn syrup instead of water for sprinkle adhesion creates rim that actually stays on glass instead of falling into drink on first sip. Don't skip shaking with ice thinking you're saving time because unshaken shots taste like you're drinking straight from bottle instead of crafted cocktail. The time I tried using regular sprinkles instead of nonpareils resulted in colors bleeding into cream making everything look muddy pink instead of festive.

Frequently Asked Questions

What kind of alcohol is used in sweet shots?

Sweet shots typically use cream liqueurs (Baileys, Kahlua), flavored vodkas, amaretto, butterscotch schnapps, or fruit liqueurs mixed with cream or juice. These mask alcohol taste creating dessert like flavors.

What liquor is in an oatmeal cookie shot?

Oatmeal cookie shots contain butterscotch schnapps, Irish cream, and cinnamon vodka or Goldschläger. Similar concept to sugar cookie shots but with butterscotch flavor instead of vanilla amaretto.

What is the sugar cookie drink at Starbucks?

Starbucks sugar cookie drinks are seasonal lattes with sugar cookie flavored syrup, vanilla, and sometimes almond flavoring. Non alcoholic coffee drinks inspired by same cookie flavor profile.

What's in a Girl Scout cookie shot?

Girl Scout cookie shots vary by cookie type. Thin Mint version uses peppermint schnapps, chocolate liqueur, and cream. Samoa version uses chocolate, coconut, and caramel flavors. Tagalong uses peanut butter and chocolate.

Sibling Rivalry Resolution

Relatives photographing my sprinkle rimmed shots while my sister's elaborate spread went ignored proved that impressive presentation sometimes beats homemade from scratch effort. Years of feeling like the less put together sibling ended when simple shots with festive decoration competed with her Pinterest perfect productions. Sometimes winning unspoken family competitions just requires finding that one thing you can execute better than the overachiever everyone else expects excellence from.

Ready for more holiday shots? Try our Sour Patch Jello Shots for fruity party favorite, or explore our Peppermint White Russian for minty coffee cocktail. For festive drinks, our White Christmas Cranberry Margarita delivers holiday twist on classic.

Share your Christmas sugar cookie shots! Tag us @HannahAndSproutKitchen with #ChristmasSugarCookieShots; we're dying to see your sprinkle rimmed shots and hear about your sibling rivalry victories!

Star ⭐️ Rate this Christmas sugar cookie shots recipe and join our community of competitive hosts!

Looking for other recipes like Christmas sugar cookie shots ? Try these:

Festive Christmas sugar cookie shots with sprinkle-rimmed glasses filled with creamy vanilla cookie liqueur.

Christmas Sugar Cookie Shots

Creamy Christmas sugar cookie shots made with vanilla vodka, amaretto, and Irish cream for a festive, dessert-like holiday cocktail. Perfect for parties, celebrations, and impressive holiday entertaining.
No ratings yet
Pin Share Print Rate
Course: Drinks
Cuisine: American
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Chill Time: 10 minutes
Total Time: 15 minutes
Servings: 8 shots
Calories: 120kcal
Author: 3178662ec14a78eb1923901e470a1eb61d070ad58e42b4ce40807f071118ba49?s=30&d=mm&r=gHannah Cooking
Cost: $12–$16 per batch

Equipment

  • Cocktail shaker (For chilling and blending)
  • Jigger (For accurate measuring)
  • Shot glasses (For serving)
  • Shallow plate (For sprinkles)
  • Small brush (For applying corn syrup to rim)

Ingredients

For the Shots

  • 1 cup Vanilla vodka - Or more for stronger shots
  • 0.5 cup Amaretto - Adds sugar cookie flavor
  • 0.5 cup Irish cream or half-and-half - Liqueur = richer, half & half = lighter
  • Ice - For shaking

For the Sprinkle Rim

  • 2 tablespoon Corn syrup or honey - Helps sprinkles stick
  • 0.33 cup Christmas sprinkles - Red, green, and white

Instructions 

  • Dip shot glass rims in corn syrup and roll in sprinkles.
  • Add vanilla vodka, amaretto, and Irish cream to shaker with ice.
  • Shake vigorously for 15 seconds until cold and creamy.
  • Strain into sprinkle-rimmed shot glasses.
  • Serve immediately while chilled.

Notes

For a richer flavor, use Irish cream; for a lighter version, substitute with half-and-half. Make ahead and chill, but shake again just before serving.

Nutrition

Serving: 1drink | Calories: 120kcal (6%) | Carbohydrates: 7g (2%) | Protein: 0.5g (1%) | Fat: 3g (5%) | Saturated Fat: 2g (13%) | Cholesterol: 6mg (2%) | Sodium: 8mg | Potassium: 40mg (1%) | Sugar: 6g (7%) | Vitamin A: 60IU (1%) | Calcium: 20mg (2%) | Iron: 0.1mg (1%)

More Drinks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating